simmer · tomato sauce
★ STARRED KITCHENPrep 5 minCook 15 minCedarforge Basic Tomato
Independent adaptation of a publicly published Andrew Carmellini recipe. Not affiliated with, sponsored by, or endorsed by Andrew Carmellini.
Basic Tomato from a starred kitchen & national award winner.
Ratio
Ingredients
- Tomato — 12 ripe beefsteak tomatoes (about 5 pounds), peeled; or 10 cups canned San Marzano
- Salt — 1 heaping tsp sea salt or kosher salt (5 ml)
- Garlic — 1 head garlic, for the flavored oil
- Olive Oil — 1 1/4 cups extra virgin olive oil (300 ml)
- Basil — 1 packed cup basil leaves, with stems on (240 ml)
- Red Pepper Fla — 1 tsp red pepper flakes (5 ml)
Method
- Pour to the lines in order (bottom → top): Salt, Olive Oil, Basil, Red Pepper Fla.
- Add: Tomato, Salt, Garlic.
- Cap the jar and shake until combined.
- Pour into a cold pan and bring to a gentle simmer. The jar stays off the stove — cool leftovers to warm-to-touch before they go back in the glass.
Keep this recipe
Tonight you'll cook it. The jar remembers it.
You found this recipe once. On a PantryFlex jar it’s printed in glass — pour your pantry to the line, shake cold, tip it into your pan. The jar measures; the stove finishes.
4 kitchens · 3 stars · 5 national awards
- Cedarforge Basic Tomato★ STARRED KITCHEN
- Bangkok Brava★ STARRED KITCHEN
- Saffronhall Jollof Tomato–pepperNATIONAL AWARD WINNER
- Simple Tomato Sauce★ STARRED KITCHEN
First run is small.
Leave an email and we’ll hold a jar with this recipe on it.
Provenance
Andrew Carmellini works in Italian-American / New American at A Voce; credentials include James Beard Rising Star Chef 2000; James Beard Best Chef: New York City 2005.
Originally published as Basic Tomato Sauce.
More from this kitchenFAQ
Can this go in a shake jar?
Yes — with one pan. Its liquids pour to the printed fill-lines and shake cold; the mix then goes into a pan to simmer. The jar itself never touches heat.
What do the quantities mean?
Amounts follow the published recipe in household units (with metric in parentheses). On a jar, every sauce scales to the same fill height.
Where did this recipe come from?
Adapted from Andrew Carmellini / CBS The Dish (grandmother's ravioli) (published as “Basic Tomato Sauce”). Full citation lives in Provenance.